How To Style Knee High Boots This Fall, Even With Shorts

Published:

|

9 minutes

A knee high boots outfit comes together fastest when you start with what goes on your legs: shorts, a mini skirt or jeans. Each one needs a slightly different top, a different kind of tights (or none), and sometimes a different boot. So decide on tomorrow’s bottom first; the boot style, the color and the fit follow from there.

Knee high boots with suit shorts

The formula: suit shorts + sheer or opaque tights + knee high boots + a blazer or long coat.

This is the big look of the season, and it’s less daring than it sounds. Suit shorts in wool, leather or suiting fabric sit high on the waist and end mid-thigh, so with knee high boots and tights only a few inches of leg show at all. The sharp cut is what keeps it grown-up: soft jersey shorts read like loungewear, while pleated wool or leather shorts read like a suit that happens to be short.

Black sheer tights are the classic pairing. They make the leg line continuous from hem to boot, so the outfit looks long and lean even with flat boots. On colder days, switch to opaque tights in black or chocolate. As a rough guide, tights labeled around 15 to 20 denier look sheer, and 40 denier and up look opaque and keep you noticeably warmer.

Length and fit matter more with shorts than with any other bottom. Look for a hem that ends a hand’s width or so below the hip, a high waist, and enough room in the leg that the shorts hang straight instead of clinging. Pleats in the front help, since they add a little volume and make the shorts look like trousers that were cut short on purpose.

The outer layer decides the mood. An oversized blazer, either black or camel, is the office-friendly version: tuck a fine knit into the shorts, add a belt, and the blazer covers the hips so the shorts look like part of a suit. A long coat that falls past the hem of the shorts is the cold-weather version; when it’s buttoned, the outfit looks like a coat and boots, and the shorts only show when you sit down.

For a lighter, early-fall version, khaki shorts with a crisp white shirt and slouchy taupe suede boots keep the same formula in softer colors. It’s a good transition outfit for the weeks when mornings are cool and afternoons still feel like summer.

Knee high boots with mini skirts

The formula: mini skirt + sheer tights + chunky sweater + knee high boots.

A mini skirt with knee high boots is the most classic combination of all, and the chunky sweater is what makes it feel like fall instead of a night out. The volume on top balances the short skirt, and the boots cover enough leg that the outfit doesn’t feel cold or overexposed.

Suede and leather minis work best, because they hold their shape and pair naturally with boot leathers. A brown suede mini with a mustard or rust knit and slouchy taupe suede boots is a soft, warm version; a black leather mini with a gray knit and black boots is the sharper one. Tuck the front of the sweater into the skirt so the waist still shows.

For colder weeks, add a coat that’s longer than the skirt. A brown teddy or wool coat over a mini, sheer black tights and black knee high boots looks finished, and only a strip of tights shows between the coat and the boots.

If you’d rather not wear a skirt that short, a denim dress or a shirt dress that ends above the knee works with the same formula. My post on why denim dresses work all year round has a few that look good with tall boots. Once it gets colder, a longer knit works as well; these knit dress outfits for winter pair ribbed maxis with boots.

Knee high boots with jeans

The formula: skinny jeans tucked in, or straight jeans worn over the boot.

Jeans and knee high boots go together in two different ways, and the jean cut decides which one.

Skinny jeans, tucked in. Slim or skinny jeans tuck neatly into the boot shaft, which gives you the riding boots outfit look: a fitted leg, a long line from hip to toe, and a sweater or coat on top. Flat or low-heeled boots suit this best. Over-the-knee boots work the same way and make the line even longer. Keep the top relaxed, like a striped knit or an oversized sweater, so the fitted lower half doesn’t look too tight.

Straight jeans, over the boot. Straight or bootcut jeans go over the boots, and only the toe and heel show. This is the most casual knee boots outfit and the easiest to wear every day, since you get the warmth of a tall boot without anything looking styled. A slim, sleek boot fits under straight jeans more smoothly than a chunky lug sole; the bulk of a wide shaft can make the jeans bunch.

Tucking wider jeans into boots rarely works, because the extra fabric bunches around the top of the shaft. If your jeans are wide, wear them over the boot or switch to a skinnier pair for the tucked look.

With either version, the top does a lot of work. A sweater or coat that covers the hips keeps tucked skinny jeans looking polished, while a cropped jacket or a tucked-in knit suits straight jeans over the boot, since it shows the waist and balances the longer leg line.

Which boot style are you working with?

The same outfit looks different depending on the boot, so it helps to know which kind you have.

Chunky lug sole. Thick, ridged rubber soles and a straight shaft. They’re the most practical for rain and city walking, and they toughen up anything feminine: a mini, a dress or sheer tights. They’re less suited to straight jeans worn over the top, since the sole sticks out.

Sleek heeled. A slim shaft and a block or stiletto heel. These are the most polished and work with suit shorts, skirts and dresses. They also fit under straight jeans better than any other style.

Slouchy suede. A soft shaft that gathers around the ankle and calf. These are the most relaxed, and they look best with minis and shorts in warm tones. Suede needs a protective spray before the first rainy day.

Kitten heel. A short, thin heel with a pointed toe. This style is everywhere this fall, and it sits between flat and heeled: dressy enough for the office, easy enough to walk in all day. A pair in chocolate suede with a black leather jacket and black shorts looks sharp without trying hard. For more ways to wear that jacket, my leather jacket outfits post goes through every cut.

For wider calves, look for wide-calf fits, stretch panels or a slouchy shaft; a plus size knee high boots outfit follows the same rules once the boot fits comfortably. Knee socks that show an inch above the boot add warmth and work well with skirts in spring and fall.

Black, brown or taupe suede?

Black knee high boots are the workhorse. A tall black boots outfit goes with black, gray, camel and denim, and black boots are the easiest to dress up for evening. They also make legs look longest with black tights, since the line doesn’t break.

Brown leather is warmer and softer. It pairs naturally with camel, cream, rust and denim, and it suits fall colors better than black. Chocolate brown can stand in for black in almost every outfit.

Taupe suede is the lightest and most relaxed. It looks best with warm neutrals, like beige shorts, a cream knit or a brown suede mini, and it softens an outfit that might otherwise look harsh. The downside is upkeep: light suede shows water marks and dirt quickly. If you like taupe with satin, my silk skirt outfits for fall include a few that pair well.

In my opinion, if you’re buying only one pair, black in a sleek or lug style covers the most outfits. Add brown or taupe suede second.

Getting the fit right

Knee high boots only look good if they fit your calf, and calf sizes vary much more than shoe sizes.

Measure the widest part of your calf with a soft tape, then compare it to the shaft circumference listed on the product page. For boots you’ll wear with tights or bare legs, a shaft about an inch wider than your calf feels comfortable without gaping. If you want to tuck in skinny jeans, add a little more room. Many brands make wide-calf versions of popular styles, and some add stretch panels or a back zip that adjusts the width.

Boots that slide down usually have a shaft that’s too wide or too soft. Slouchy styles are meant to gather, but straight shafts shouldn’t. A few fixes: wear tights with a grip finish, add clear boot-strap tape inside the top of the shaft, or ask a shoe repair shop to take in the shaft or add an elastic gusset.

Height matters too. A knee high boot should end just below the bend of your knee. If the shaft hits the back of your knee when you sit, it will dig in all day; if it stops too low on the calf, it can cut the leg at an awkward point.

Shorts with tights and a blazer, a mini with a chunky knit, skinny jeans tucked in or straight jeans over the top: choose the bottom first, the boot second, and keep the shaft fitted to your calf.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: